|
Katherine Lamphier / Kalamazoo 1. Melancholia 2. Beautiful Boy 3. Le Havre 4. A Separation 5. Martha Marcy May Marlene 6. Of Gods and Men 7. Take Shelter 8. Midnight in Paris 9. The Artist 10. Tabloid
Stephanie Zacharek / Movieline 1. The Artist 2. Melancholia 3. Tinker, Tailer, Soldier, Spy 4. Midnight in Paris 5. Jane Eyre 6. Le Havre 7. Bill Cunningham New York 8. Pina 9. Cave of Forgotten Dreams 10. Drive
Stephen Holden / The New York Times 1. The Descendants 2. Of Gods and Men 3. The Tree of Life 4. Margin Call 5. Melancholia 6. We Were Here 7. Incendies 8. A Dangerous Method 9. Certified Copy 10. Moneyball
Joe Morgenstern / The Wall Street Journal 1. A Separation 2. The Artist 3. Bridesmaids 4. Buck 5. The Descendants 6. Midnight in Paris 7. Moneyball 8. Of Gods and Men 9. The Tree of Life 10. Young Adult
A.O. Scott / The New York Times 1. Bridesmaids 2. A Brighter Summer Day 3. Cedar Rapids 4. A Dangerous Method 5. The Descendants 6. The Future 7. The Help 8. Incendies 9. Into the Abyss 10. Margin Call 11. Meek's Cutoff 12. Mysteries of Lisbon 13. Le Quattro Volte 14. The Tree of Life 15. Tuesday, After Christmas 16. War Horse 17. Warrior 18. Weekend 19. Weekend 20. Wiinie the Pooh 21. Young Adult
Roger Ebert / Chicago Sun-Times 1. A Separation 2. Shame 3. The Tree of Life 4. Hugo 5. Take Shelter 6. Kinyarwanda 7. Drive 8. Midnight in Paris 9. Le Havre 10. The Artist
Michael Phillips / The Chicago Tribune 1. Poetry 2. Moneyball 3. Certified Copy 4. The Descendants 5. The Interrupters 6. Guy and Madeline on a Park Bench 7. A Separation 8. The Tree of Life 9. Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy 10. Weekend
Kenneth Turan / Los Angeles Times 1. The Clock 2. The Artist 3. City of Life and Death 4. Like Crazy 5. Midnight in Paris 6. Of Gods and Men 7. Poetry 8. A Separation 9. Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy 10. Win Win
Ty Burr / The Boston Globe 1. Hugo 2. Drive 3. The Clock 4. The Artist 5. Le Quattro Volte 6. A Separation 7. Bill Cunningham New York 8. Moneyball 9. Win Win 10. Limitless
Mike Giuliano / Baltimore Sun 1. Hugo 2. The Artist 3. Cave of Forgotten Dreams 4. The Descendants 5. Midnight in Paris 6. The Tree of LIfe 7. Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, Part 2 8. Moneyball 9. Nostalgia for the Light 10. Rise of the Planet of the Apes
The American Film Institute 1. The Descendants 2. The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo 3. The Help 4. J. Edgar 5. Hugo 6. Midnight in Paris 7. Moneyball 8. The Tree of Life 9. War Horse 10. Bridesmaids
J. Hoberman / The Village Voice 1. A Dangerous Method 2. Melancholia 3. Mysteries of Lisbon 4. Aurora 5. Seekign the Monkey King 6. To Die Like a Man 7. Uncle Boonmee Who Can Recall His Past Lives 8. Hugo 9. J. Edgar 10. United Red Army
J. R. Jones / Chicago Reader 1. Of Gods and Men 2. Bridesmaids 3. The Tree of Life 4. Terri 5. Tabloid 6. Client 9: The Rise and Fall of Eliot Spitzer 7. The Elephant in the Living Room 8. The Wise Kids 9. Beautiful Boy 10. Margin Call
Lisa Kennedy / The Denver Post 1. Moneyball 2. The Tree of LIfe 3. Martha Marcy May Marlene 4. Extremely Loud & Incredibly Close 5. The Descendants 6. Bridesmaids 7. Beginners 8. A Separation 9. Hugo 10. Nostalgia for the Light
Amy Biancolli / The Houston Chronicle 1. The Artist 2. Midnight in Paris 3. The Descendants 4. Bill Cunningham New York 5. Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, Psrt 2 6. The Illusionist 7. Nostalgia for the Light 8. Of Gods and Men 9. The Adventures of Tintin 10. Take Shelter
Shawn Levy / The Oregonian 1. Hugo 2. The Interrupters 3. The Guard 4. Mildred Pierce 5. How to Die in Oregon 6. On the Bowery 7. Rango 8. The Skin I Live In 9. We Need to Talk About Kevin 10. Beginners
Andrew O'Hehir / Salon 1. Poetry 2. Melancholia 3. Take Shelter 4. Coriolanus 5. Mysteries of Lisbon 6. A Separation 7. Drive 8. Uncle Boonmee Who Can Recall His Past Lives 9. Meek's Cutoff 10. Putty Hill
|